The US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit confirmed that ROSS Intelligence infringed Thomson Reuters’ copyright by using summaries from the Westlaw legal database to train its artificial intelligence-based search engine, and that such use does not qualify as fair use. This is the first ruling by a US federal court of appeals on the application of fair use to the training of artificial intelligence systems.
The dispute dates back to 2020, when Thomson Reuters, the owner of Westlaw, sued ROSS, a start-up developing a search engine capable of answering questions put in natural language with passages drawn from some ten million judicial opinions. To train it, ROSS turned to a third-party company, LegalEase, which prepared around 25,000 memoranda using thousands of Westlaw headnotes, that is, the summaries of points of law written by the database’s editors. In 2021 ROSS ceased operations, citing the costs of the litigation. In February 2025 the trial judge found that 2,243 headnotes had been copied and rejected the fair use defence, allowing an immediate appeal on the two central questions in the case: whether the headnotes are protectable and whether fair use applies.
On the first point, the Court held that the headnotes are original works. The required threshold of creativity, the judges observed, is extremely low, and it is met by the editorial choices through which the editors identify the relevant points of law and decide how to phrase them, in compliance with internal criteria such as an 800-character limit and the requirement that each headnote be understandable without the opinion. The Court also rejected the argument that protecting the headnotes would amount to a monopoly over the law: headnotes are not the law, but one of the many forms in which a legal principle can be expressed.
As to fair use, the Court characterised the use as highly commercial and, at most, minimally transformative, since both Westlaw and ROSS’s search engine serve to locate relevant legal material. It also ruled out that the copying was necessary: ROSS had access to the opinions, which are freely available, and chose the headnotes only because they were more convenient to use, whereas convenience, unlike necessity, does not justify reproducing a protected work. The predominantly factual nature of the headnotes tipped the factor concerning the nature of the work slightly in ROSS’s favour, while the factor concerning the amount used was resolved in favour of Thomson Reuters, since each headnote is a self-standing work and was copied in its entirety.
The factor concerning the effect on the market proved decisive. According to the Court, widespread copying of this kind to build competing products would harm Westlaw’s position; above all, the judges recognised the existence of a rapidly developing derivative market, namely the licensing of text content as training data for artificial intelligence, which Thomson Reuters already exploits for its own products. By using the headnotes without authorisation, ROSS appropriated that commercial opportunity.
The scope of the decision is, however, subject to precise limits, pointed out by the Court itself. ROSS’s system did not generate new content but merely returned passages from existing opinions, and the judges expressly distinguished the case from disputes concerning generative artificial intelligence, which are currently at the heart of numerous proceedings in the United States. The judgment was also handed down on an immediate appeal, with the first-instance proceedings yet to be concluded. ROSS has announced its intention to petition the Supreme Court.

